Can poor science models still be useful for teaching science? Follow FizzicsEd Articles: Comments 0 This might be counter-intuitive but sometimes presenting poorly designed scientific models to students can be extremely helpful in allowing students to critically analyse a given topic area. This week I was teaching a Stars & Planets workshop to primary school students and we started tearing apart the solar system model shown below: Solar system model: basically it’s terrible…and useful! Of course, as you’d expect of a school science incursion we bring all the ‘whiz-bang stuff’ to show the students but for this hands-on station it is very useful to use the solar system pictured above as a way of having students brainstorm all things wrong about the model… and believe me, there are a LOT of issues: The size ratios of the Sun compared to planets are completely out. The distances between each planet and to the Sun are totally wrong. Where are the moons? For that matter, what about the asteroid belt, the Kuiper belt or the Oort cloud? The Sun is missing sunspots, solar flares and is even the wrong colour (it’s a yellow dwarf after all). Mercury is completely smooth instead of pockmarked with craters. Venus should be white-ish yellow reflecting the presence of a carbon dioxide atmosphere laden with sulfur. Earth has no continents, tundra, weather systems or polar caps. Mars is missing it’s northern polar ice cap. Jupiter has no gaseous banding or rotating storms shown (nor does any of the other gas giants either). Saturn is missing its icy rings, and that’s the same with Jupiter, Uranus and Neptune. If we were only showing planets and our Sun, why is Pluto there if it’s classified as a Dwarf Planet? The orbits paths are completely circular instead of elliptical… … and the list goes on! Now, of course, you could call this being picky (it is, in reality, a $30 model), but that is actually the point – if students can critically analyse how bad a scientific model is, it means that they really do know their content and can demonstrate scientific literacy. In the case of the school science visit, we spent 45 minutes going to town on how bad the model was and I must say I had to stop them as we only were at the school for half a day and had other things to do too! The aftermath of the intense 45 minutes of student interrogation was 2 whiteboards completely filled with highly informative facts and figures about what should be included in an ideal model of the solar system… and the booking teacher could not have been happier. In a short space of time, the kids had been taught to question what is presented to them, form their own opinion, research the facts and collectively contribute to a better model that they would prefer… thereby emulating thought processes used in the development of new ideas as well as undertaking teamwork around a common goal. What’s the moral to this story? Even if you can’t get the exact scientific model to use in demonstrating a concept it is the very flaws you can find that can be used as the greatest source for inspired learning. All the best! Ben Newsome. Explore space further with the Fizzics team! NEW Primary science teaching book! “Be Amazing! How to teach science, the way primary kids love” Want more ideas for teaching science? Subscribe to the FizzicsEd Podcast! Love Science? Subscribe! Join our newsletter Receive more lesson plans and fun science ideas. PROGRAMS COURSES SHOP SCIENCE PARTIES Calendar of Events HIGH SCHOOL Science@Home 4-Week Membership 12PM: March 2024 Feb 26, 2024 - Mar 29, 2024 12PM - 12PM Price: $50 - $900 Book Now! PRIMARY Science@Home 4-Week Membership 2PM: March 2024 Feb 26, 2024 - Mar 22, 2024 2PM - 2PM Price: $50 - $900 Book Now! Light and Colour Online Workshop, Jan 18 PM Jan 18, 2024 2PM - 3PM Price: $50 Book Now! Light and Colour Online Workshop, Jan 18 AM Jan 18, 2024 9AM - 11AM Price: $50 Book Now! Lego Robotics, Sydney Olympic Park Jan 2024 Jan 24, 2024 9AM - 12PM Price: $50 Book Now! Creative Coding, Sydney Olympic Park Jan 2024 Jan 24, 2024 1PM - 4PM Price: $50 Book Now! Creative Coding, Sydney Olympic Park July 11 2023 Jul 11, 2023 9AM - 4PM Price: $100 Book Now! Fizzics Education STEAM Day: Robots vs Dinosaurs, Lalor, Apr 14 Apr 14, 2023 9AM - 12PM Price: $45 - $50 Book Now! Creative Coding, Sydney Olympic Park April 14 2023 Apr 14, 2023 9AM - 4PM Price: $100 Book Now! Science@Home After School 4-Week Membership: March 2023 Mar 06, 2023 - Mar 31, 2023 4PM - 5PM Price: $40 - $1200 Book Now! Featured Articles Teachers Toolbox – inexpensive materials that teach science at a pinch Topics China [1] Food [4] Outreach [35] STEM [217] Physics [6] Global [2] K to 2 education [1] Virtual reality [2] citizen science [1] Churchill Fellowship [19] Gaming [7] Ozscied [2] Teaching [262] Chemistry [5] International [1] Photography [1] Play [1] Cleveland [1] Gifted [7] Podcasts [119] Television [2] design thinking [8] Chinese student visits [1] Parenting [4] preservice teaching [5] Club [4] History [4] Pop Culture [4] Toys & Gadgets [1] project-based learning [5] Science & Technology Camps [1] Lesson ideas [1] Comedy [2] Coding [14] Indigenous [3] Preschool [24] Video Conferencing [40] family [2] Design [2] Lab Tech [1] math [1] Cooking [3] Kids [36] Remote Education [16] Virtual Excursions [9] Inclusive education [6] Oceans [5] Leadership [1] Electricity [1] Dinosaurs [7] Kids Parties [5] Robotics [10] Edutech [26] Classroom management [1] video conference [1] special needs [1] scholarship [1] Apps [11] Distance Education [50] Kitchen Chemistry [7] Safety [2] Distance Learning [19] Student encouragement [2] online [4] image [1] Africa [1] Agriculture [4] Eastershow [2] Maker Space [11] Scicomm [141] primary education [46] STEAM [9] virtual [2] gamification [1] Asia Pacific [1] Art [17] Edchat [223] Maths [14] Scied [34] literacy [6] Higher education [4] Child online safety [1] Esports [1] Easter [1] Augmented Reality [4] Edtech [68] Media [18] Science [6] secondary education [44] teacher [1] dis [0] biotechnology [1] curriculum [2] AussieED [1] Education [207] Museums [31] Science News [4] Christmas [1] Vacation care [1] Film [1] computational thinking [2] high [1] Awards [13] Educhange [5] Music [2] Social Media [8] experiments [6] middle school [2] Inquiry-based learning [5] digital technologies [5] Earth science [1] Big History [1] Environment [37] NASA [6] Soils [1] seasonal [1] Artificial Intelligence [3] List [1] Games [1] Medicine [1] Biology [43] Events [45] National Science Week [3] Space Science [27] competitions [12] Sustainability [8] Student investigation [2] Social Emotional Learning [1] CAST test [1] Books [3] Farming [1] Outdoors [36] Sport [8] careers [10] UN SDGs [4] collaboration [1] Engineering [4] US Education [1] Load More Topics
This might be counter-intuitive but sometimes presenting poorly designed scientific models to students can be extremely helpful in allowing students to critically analyse a given topic area. This week I was teaching a Stars & Planets workshop to primary school students and we started tearing apart the solar system model shown below: Solar system model: basically it’s terrible…and useful! Of course, as you’d expect of a school science incursion we bring all the ‘whiz-bang stuff’ to show the students but for this hands-on station it is very useful to use the solar system pictured above as a way of having students brainstorm all things wrong about the model… and believe me, there are a LOT of issues: The size ratios of the Sun compared to planets are completely out. The distances between each planet and to the Sun are totally wrong. Where are the moons? For that matter, what about the asteroid belt, the Kuiper belt or the Oort cloud? The Sun is missing sunspots, solar flares and is even the wrong colour (it’s a yellow dwarf after all). Mercury is completely smooth instead of pockmarked with craters. Venus should be white-ish yellow reflecting the presence of a carbon dioxide atmosphere laden with sulfur. Earth has no continents, tundra, weather systems or polar caps. Mars is missing it’s northern polar ice cap. Jupiter has no gaseous banding or rotating storms shown (nor does any of the other gas giants either). Saturn is missing its icy rings, and that’s the same with Jupiter, Uranus and Neptune. If we were only showing planets and our Sun, why is Pluto there if it’s classified as a Dwarf Planet? The orbits paths are completely circular instead of elliptical… … and the list goes on! Now, of course, you could call this being picky (it is, in reality, a $30 model), but that is actually the point – if students can critically analyse how bad a scientific model is, it means that they really do know their content and can demonstrate scientific literacy. In the case of the school science visit, we spent 45 minutes going to town on how bad the model was and I must say I had to stop them as we only were at the school for half a day and had other things to do too! The aftermath of the intense 45 minutes of student interrogation was 2 whiteboards completely filled with highly informative facts and figures about what should be included in an ideal model of the solar system… and the booking teacher could not have been happier. In a short space of time, the kids had been taught to question what is presented to them, form their own opinion, research the facts and collectively contribute to a better model that they would prefer… thereby emulating thought processes used in the development of new ideas as well as undertaking teamwork around a common goal. What’s the moral to this story? Even if you can’t get the exact scientific model to use in demonstrating a concept it is the very flaws you can find that can be used as the greatest source for inspired learning. All the best! Ben Newsome. Explore space further with the Fizzics team! NEW Primary science teaching book! “Be Amazing! How to teach science, the way primary kids love” Want more ideas for teaching science? Subscribe to the FizzicsEd Podcast!
This website uses cookies to improve user experience. By using our website you consent to all cookies in accordance with our Cookie Policy.
Thank you for looking to subscribing to our newsletter 🙂 Through this service you’ll be first to know about the newest free experiments, science news and special offers. PLUS: Get a free Kitchen Chemistry Booklet with >20 experiments, how to use variables plus a handy template!
Please fill out the details below and an email will be sent to you. Once you get that just click on the link to confirm your subscription and you're all done!